Ambitions and Resistance in China’s Talent Strategy and Energy Diplomacy

Article

This analysis compares two academic papers discussing various aspects of China’s ascent as a global power. The first study, by Zweig et al. (2020), examines the return of domestic talent to and from China, investigating obstacles encountered by overseas scholars upon re-integrating into domestic institutions. ...

Between Ambitions and Resistance: A Comparative Study of China’s Talent Strategy and Energy Diplomacy

 
ANALYSES OF THE ARTICLES

‘The Best are yet to Come:’ State Programs, Domestic Resistance and Riverse Migration of High-level Talent to China
David ZWEIG, Siqin KANG & Dr. Huiyao WANG (2020)

Sino-Russian Strategic Energy Ties: Enduring Partnership or Fragile Bonds?
Dr. Miyeon OH (2016)

ABSTRACT

This analysis compares two academic papers discussing various aspects of China’s ascent as a global power. The first study, by Zweig et al. (2020), examines the return of domestic talent to and from China, investigating obstacles encountered by overseas scholars upon re-integrating into domestic institutions. The second article, authored by Oh (2016), analyzes Chinese strategic energy cooperation with Russia, focusing on political and economic challenges that may impede the partnership. While their subjects differ, both articles share a common theme: the distance between China’s ambitious aspirations and the internal and external obstacles the country faces. By examining these two cases together, the paper demonstrates that China’s development strategy remains driven by state-led planning but is constrained by institutional resistance and international complexity. The analysis suggests that China’s push for global influence needs more than just strong policies; it also requires cooperation, reform, and long-term trust.

Keywords: China, global strategy, energy diplomacy, institutional barriers, Sino-Russian relations

INTRODUCTION

In recent decades, China has become more active in global politics, economy, and science. The country wants to grow its influence by becoming a leader in important areas like energy and scientific innovation. To reach these goals, China has created many state-led programs and international partnerships. However, China faces some challenges inside the country and in its relations with other states.

This analysis focuses on two articles that study China’s global strategies and the obstacles it faces. The first article is by David Zweig, Siqin Kang, and Dr. Huiyao Wang (2020), titled “The best are yet to come: State Programs, Domestic Resistance and Reverse Migration of High-level Talent to China“. This article explains how China tries to bring back talented scientists and experts from abroad through special national programs. However, many of the best minds do not return full-time because of problems in China’s academic and institutional environment.

The second article is by Miyeon Oh (2016), titled “Sino-Russian Strategic Energy Ties: Enduring Partnership or Fragile Bonds?“. This study looks at China’s and Russia’s cooperation on energy, especially natural gas. It focuses on the strategic gas deals between the two countries and the political, economic, and technical problems that make the cooperation difficult and uncertain.
Both articles show that China is working hard to become a strong global actor. But they also show that internal resistance and fragile international partnerships are big barriers to this ambition. This comparative analysis will explore how China’s domestic and foreign policies reflect the country’s struggle between big dreams and real-world limitations. It will also examine how the authors use different research methods and what we can learn from their findings.

METHODOLOGICAL ASPECTS

The two articles analyzed in this study deal with different subjects; one focused on China’s talent return policies, the other on strategic energy cooperation with Russia. But they have at their core a similar theme: China’s ambition to be a global power and the institutional and geopolitical constraints that make its aspirations difficult to achieve. Both articles illustrate, through various case studies, that China’s state-led approach is hampered by domestic resistance and precarious international relations.
 
This content is protected by Copyright under the Trademark Certificate. It may be partially quoted, provided that the source is cited, its link is given and the name and title of the editor/author (if any) is mentioned exactly the same. When these conditions are fulfilled, there is no need for additional permission. However, if the content is to be used entirely, it is absolutely necessary to obtain written permission from TASAM.

Areas

Continents ( 5 Fields )
Action
 Contents ( 487 ) Actiivities ( 223 )
Areas
TASAM Africa 0 153
TASAM Asia 0 244
TASAM Europe 0 44
TASAM Latin America & Carribea... 0 34
TASAM North America 0 12
Regions ( 4 Fields )
Action
 Contents ( 182 ) Actiivities ( 56 )
Areas
TASAM Balkans 0 95
TASAM Middle East 0 64
TASAM Black Sea and Caucasus 0 16
TASAM Mediterranean 0 7
Identity Fields ( 2 Fields )
Action
 Contents ( 176 ) Actiivities ( 75 )
Areas
TASAM Islamic World 0 147
TASAM Turkic World 0 29
TASAM Türkiye ( 1 Fields )
Action
 Contents ( 234 ) Actiivities ( 62 )
Areas
TASAM Türkiye 0 234

Global energy influence increasingly depends on the ability to connect resources, processing facilities and consumers across politically fragmented markets. India illustrates this transformation. ;

In recent years, the Central Asian region has attracted attention due to its global significance. Following Russia's 2022 attack on Ukraine, a war involving large-scale military operations ensued. ;

In international relations even nations with competing interests have strong incentives to interact with each other. Recently, Chinese President Xi Jinping and Indian Prime Minister Modi met each other on the sidelines of the 18th BRICS Summit that fueled speculation that two sides are inching close...;

Lasting security arrangements arise not from shared values, but from the recognition by the parties that they cannot eliminate one another.;

Earlier this month, three leaders stood together in Islam's holiest city and signed a document that became a headline. The Mecca Joint Defence Agreement, sealed by Saudi Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman, Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan and Pakistani Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif, commits each...;

The famous teachings of Confucius, in the author's opinion, anticipated the appearance of the doctrine promoted in the article - synthesizing realism. The new teaching is designed to combine in one philosophical image of the world the three main branches of the development of modern philosophy – obj...;

The Arctic is increasingly becoming a laboratory for the interaction between sanctions, energy security, maritime logistics and great-power competition. One of the clearest examples is the emerging China-Russia Arctic LNG relationship. Western sanctions have sharply constrained Russia’s Arctic LNG 2...;

In recent years, the Arctic has become a central arena not only in the context of climate change, melting sea ice, and new maritime routes, but also in terms of energy geopolitics and great-power competition. One of the most striking examples of this transformation is China-Russia;

9th Türkiye - Gulf Defence and Security Forum

  • 27 Nov 2025 - 28 Nov 2025
  • Wish More Hotel Istanbul -
  • İstanbul -

7th Marine and Maritime Security Forum

  • 27 Nov 2025 - 28 Nov 2025
  • Wish More Hotel Istanbul -
  • İstanbul -

4th Istanbul Cybersecurity Forum

  • 27 Nov 2025 - 28 Nov 2025
  • Wish More Hotel Istanbul -
  • İstanbul -

8th Türkiye - Africa Defence Security and Aerospace Forum

  • 27 Nov 2025 - 28 Nov 2025
  • Wish More Hotel Istanbul -
  • İstanbul -

2nd Asia Anew Security Forum

  • 27 Nov 2025 - 28 Nov 2025
  • Wish More Hotel Istanbul -
  • İstanbul -

11th Istanbul Security Conference (2025)

  • 27 Nov 2025 - 28 Nov 2025
  • Wish More Hotel Istanbul -
  • İstanbul -

1st Asia Anew Security Forum

  • 21 Nov 2024 - 22 Nov 2024
  • İstanbul - Türkiye

East Mediterranean Program 2023-2025

  • 17 Jul 2023 - 19 Jul 2023
  • Sheraton Istanbul City Center -
  • İstanbul - Türkiye