Conflict Resilience in Iraq's Peacebuilding

Article

Building institutions with ‘integrity’ is important as it requires the population as well as political elites to invest in the system, as what Elkins and Sides refer to as ‘state attachment’ or, more generally, state legitimacy....

Shun-Wen WANG
Chinese Culture University

1. Introduction
 
Building institutions with ‘integrity’ is important as it requires the population as well as political elites to invest in the system, as what Elkins and Sides refer to as ‘state attachment’ or, more generally, state legitimacy (Mac-Queen, 2013:46). However, ensuring short-term security and inclusion is often at the expense of the long-term viability, functionality and legitimacy. Shortterm stability sometimes needs to ‘trade-off’ with elites, warlords or sectarian leaders(Akbarzadeh et.al., 2013: 47). As such, elections, the allocation of resources, governmental arrangements (e.g. federalism), ministerial appointments, even the appointment of senior posts are allocated according to these politicized identities, and leads to further divisions among elites (Akbarzadeh et.al., 2013:48).
 
Gisselquist(2015) pointed that there are three reasons why some interventions work better than others, including (1) the area of the intervention and the related degree of engagement with domestic state institutions; (2) local contextual factors, in particular windows of opportunity, capacity and the existence of local supporters; and (3) programme design and management(Gisselquist, 2015: 284). While the last one is easier to be calculated through the results, the first two are harder to prove it. These lead to the questions of “top-down“ or “bottom up“ and the mechanism to achieve it.
 
Benjamin Isaham thinks the case of Iraq shows ‘top-down’ governing way is not enough in the process of state from despotism to democracy. In order to move on, sometimes it needs to set aside the disputes and coordinate with different actors(Isaham, 2014: 160-1). In this aspect, federalism seems to be the best way to share the power and prevent return of totalitarian politics or “strong-man“ politics.
 
As we can see in the recent conflicts after the independence referendum of Kurdish Regional Government(KRG), it demonstrated the doubt from the Arabs that Kurds were using federalism to its independence. Also, how to arrange the benefit from oil-rich provinces causes another problem. It might leads to the contradiction from the Shiite’s central government and the Sunnis-based Basra or Kurds-based Kirkuk(Kane et al., 2012:20-21).
 
Lack of infrastructure and mechanism is also the problem for building integrity. Local governments always complained on the lack of budget during the CPA period. Central government in Bagdad doesn’t have sufficient ability to manage local affairs, but they still don’t want to give the power to local leaders. According to an interview of the mayor in Tikrit, the mayor complained that many local officials make a report directly to province or Bagdad, not him. Also, because the lack of resources, local government cannot respond to the public’s need (Dobbins et al., 2009:139-140). Not only the institutional problems, this paper considers interests and cognition issues might be much more important in peacebuilding and conflict resilience. “Interests“ in this paper means that different actors might have different ideas or needs in the peacebuilding process. Hence, if the conflict resilience processes don’t meet their interests, they will prefer not to cooperate and be a trouble-maker as Sunnis did.

The “cognitive“ side leads to the roots of peace: how the actors(interveners, elites and the public) view as the future road to go or to stay in the same country? This is much more important to establish the social contract and make the conflict more resilient. In the first part, I will introduce ideas from peacebuilding and conflict resilience. Then, I will start from the institutional side, as many scholars think that federalism as a solution to make peace. Since it has also many disadvantages, however, we will continue with the interests and cognitive aspects to ask: If not federalism, then? It will lead to the depth of peace in Iraq. By examining the depth of peace(through some NGOs efforts and the interviews), it will help us to find out if there is a possibility to find the conflict resilience in Iraq’s peacebuilding.

Link to the related book: New Security Ecosystem and Multilateral Cost
 
This content is protected by Copyright under the Trademark Certificate. It may be partially quoted, provided that the source is cited, its link is given and the name and title of the editor/author (if any) is mentioned exactly the same. When these conditions are fulfilled, there is no need for additional permission. However, if the content is to be used entirely, it is absolutely necessary to obtain written permission from TASAM.

Areas

Continents ( 5 Fields )
Action
 Contents ( 472 ) Actiivities ( 219 )
Areas
TASAM Africa 0 149
TASAM Asia 0 236
TASAM Europe 0 44
TASAM Latin America & Carribea... 0 34
TASAM North America 0 9
Regions ( 4 Fields )
Action
 Contents ( 178 ) Actiivities ( 54 )
Areas
TASAM Balkans 0 93
TASAM Middle East 0 62
TASAM Black Sea and Caucasus 0 16
TASAM Mediterranean 0 7
Identity Fields ( 2 Fields )
Action
 Contents ( 176 ) Actiivities ( 75 )
Areas
TASAM Islamic World 0 147
TASAM Turkic World 0 29
TASAM Türkiye ( 1 Fields )
Action
 Contents ( 229 ) Actiivities ( 60 )
Areas
TASAM Türkiye 0 229

With all its co-events, the Istanbul Security Conference, to be held for the tenth time this year, will be organized on November 21-22, 2024, with global participation under the main theme of "Technopolitics New World: Security of Security - Mind, Generation, Family, Faith, and State Security" by TA...;

Although after the war ends, Ukraine will most certainly keep its status of an independent state, the final quality of its statehood and nationhood is undefined. Russia’s ongoing destruction of Ukraine has already changed its demographic, economic and social structure with the most severe long-term ...;

In the 100th year of the Republic, on 23-24 November 2023, the 9th Istanbul Security Conference titled as "Strategic Transformation in the Ecosystem" will be held by TASAM-NDSI with global participation at Istanbul Kent University Kağıthane Campus. Last day to register is today, and the Participants...;

2nd Istanbul Cyber-Security Forum titled as “New Cyber Economy and Turkish Products“ will be held as a co-activity in the first day of the 9th Istanbul Security Conference to be held on 23-24 November 2023 at Istanbul Kent University Kağıthane Campus by TASAM - NDSI. The deadline to register is Nove...;

9th Istanbul Security Conference titled as "Strategic Transformation in the Ecosystem" will be held by TASAM-NDSI with participation on a global scale at Istanbul Kent University Kağıthane Campus. The deadline to apply for participation is November 21. The conference participants will be given certi...;

In order for Türkiye - Yemen relations to be carried to an ideal point in today’s multi-dimensional world order; every parameter should be taken into consideration. The aims of the Program are to prepare a civil, institutional and intellectual strategic base to improve and strengthened the Türkiye -...;

Although during the Russian war in Ukraine, Belarus may be qualified as a Russian proxy, paradoxically, it can be as well perceived as a country struggling to save the rest of its independence from Moscow. ;

Artificial intelligence has become an important turning point of technological developments. Especially with the use of this technology a transformation process has begun in our lives. Systems developed and under development together with artificial intelligence technology: for example, the developm...;

East Mediterranean Program 2023-2025

  • 17 Jul 2023 - 19 Jul 2023
  • Sheraton Istanbul City Center -
  • İstanbul - Türkiye

5th Marine and Maritime Security Forum

  • 23 Nov 2023 - 24 Nov 2023
  • Istanbul Kent University Kağıthane Campus -
  • İstanbul - Türkiye

2nd Istanbul Cyber-Security Forum

  • 23 Nov 2023 - 24 Nov 2023
  • Istanbul Kent University Kağıthane Campus -
  • İstanbul - Türkiye

6th Türkiye - Africa Defence Security and Aerospace Forum

  • 23 Nov 2023 - 24 Nov 2023
  • Istanbul Kent University Kağıthane Campus -
  • İstanbul - Türkiye